Whitepaper Rugged Bildwechsel 2021
White Paper

White Paper: Robustness in Connectors

Whether in aerospace, industrial automation, transportation, or healthcare, connectors must always ensure reliable signal transmission and must not fail under any circumstances. At the same time, they are exposed to a range of environmental stresses: Mechanical stresses such as shock, vibration, and oscillations jeopardize the stability of data transmission, as do thermal and chemical environmental influences caused by extreme temperatures, significant temperature fluctuations, harmful gases, moisture, and dirt. Manufacturers of high-quality connectors therefore employ a wide range of measures to protect their connectors against these stresses. 

Ruggedness despite miniaturization

Groessenvergleich
Fig. 1: Distortion of the useful signal in a shielded (left) and unshielded (right) connector.
Modern electrical engineering is subject to one trend more than ever: miniaturization. Assemblies and their components must not only become increasingly powerful, but also increasingly smaller. Yet they are often used in harsh real-world conditions. Components, including connectors, are therefore becoming increasingly delicate while withstanding the same level of stress. A high-quality connector, however, not only withstands this stress just as well as its older and larger counterpart, but even better. The reason for this lies in advancements in material composition and product design, such as in the geometry of the insulating body (Fig. 1).

Surface as an influencing factor

Abrieb Oberflaeche
Fig. 2: Abrasion and corrosion of the contact surface
 A variety of factors affect the durability of a connector. One of these is the contact surface. This plays a key role in determining the connector’s service life, which is typically measured in mating cycles. During field use, the connector is subjected to certain micro-movements. These lead to surface abrasion and, consequently, to oxidation (Fig. 2).

The result is increased contact resistance and, consequently, poorer signal transmission quality. It is therefore essential to minimize surface wear during mating and operation by using a high-quality, durable contact coating. To achieve this, both the blade and spring contacts must have a sufficiently smooth surface. Despite rising prices, gold is still widely used today for surface coatings due to its corrosion resistance and excellent conductivity. Since pure gold is soft, it is alloyed with 0.2 to 0.3 percent cobalt or nickel to produce hard gold. However, those seeking a more price-stable alternative to this coating structure can, for example, opt for an alloy of nickel and phosphorus with a gold flash. When combined in very specific proportions, these two materials exhibit the positive properties that gold also offers: high corrosion resistance, pronounced wear resistance, and excellent conductivity. To prevent diffusion between the contact material and the surface coating, a so-called nickel barrier layer is often used. This barrier helps prevent corrosion.

Contact design as an influencing factor

ept f g w 150x
Fig. 3: Spring tulip of the One27 after the punch-bending process
The contacts of a connector are stamped or turned. However, during stamping, an uneven, sharp-edged surface forms on the underside of the stamped strip that is visible under a microscope. Conventional systems make contact at this stamped edge, which results in increased surface abrasion and thus higher contact resistance. This can be avoided by bending the spring tulip 90 degrees in a so-called stamping-bending process, so that it contacts the blade contact with its smooth, rolled surface (Fig. 3).
 
However, it is not only the design of the spring strip but also that of the blade strip that is crucial for the connector’s longevity. This is because the blade strip must also be cleanly punched and further processed to avoid defective, sharp geometries.

Contact system as an influencing factor

Doppelseitiger Federkontakt
Fig. 4: Schematic illustration: double-sided spring contact of the One27 without (left) and with shock impact (right)
Traditional two-part connectors feature a blade contact and a spring contact. However, in the event of a strong shock, the blade strip can detach from the spring strip. To prevent such a contact interruption, a double-sided spring strip can be used to provide redundancy and thus ensure contact reliability, as the second spring ensures that signal transmission is maintained at all times via at least one contact point (Fig. 4).
Schnitt Doppelkontakt
Fig. 2: Optimization of ept Colibri® connectors from 10+ Gbit/s to 16+ Gbit/s
In contrast, connectors with a so-called “gender-neutral” contact system are even more robust. The key feature here is that the contact geometries of the two connector halves—the plug and the socket—are identical. Both therefore feature both a spring and a blade. This ensures that each pin is contacted by two springs, while the plug and socket are interlocked and cannot separate from one another. While a double-sided spring strip always ensures at least one contact point under mechanical stress, the interlocking geometries in gender-neutral contact systems ensure that signal transmission always occurs via two contact points. This high level of redundancy thus enables maximum contact reliability (Fig. 5).
Schliffbild Verguss
Fig. 6: Cross-sectional view of a two-piece connector vs. a one-piece flexilinkb-t-b after potting
In terms of ruggedness, the gender-neutral contact system is surpassed only by one-piece connectors. These connectors completely eliminate the traditional two-part contact design consisting of a blade and a spring strip. By eliminating the vulnerable contact area, single-piece connectors not only offer the highest resistance to shock, vibration, moisture, dust, and atmospheric conditions, but are also suitable for potting and other component protection methods. In combination with the press-fit technique, they represent the most secure mechanical and electrical connection between two printed circuit boards (Fig. 6). 


Connection technology as a contributing factor

Bild Einpressen 4c
Fig. 7: The press-fitting process
There are various ways to mount connectors on printed circuit boards. One of these is the press-fit technique mentioned earlier. Its goal is to achieve the highest possible retention forces between the connector and the PCB while using the lowest possible insertion force. These holding forces define the mechanical connection, which must withstand shock and vibration. This connection technology is a proven method used billions of times, in which a press-fit pin is pressed into a plated-through hole in the PCB (Fig. 7). 
schnitt tcom press 02
Fig. 8: Microscopic image of ept’s proprietary Tcom press® press-fit zone
  In this process, the press-fit pin has a larger diagonal dimension than the diameter of the PCB hole. The connector pin is flexible in the press-fit zone so that the PCB is not deformed by the physical forces during the press-fit process. Deformation is therefore limited to the press-fit zone (Fig. 8). A cold weld forms between the contact pin and the metallized PCB hole: a gas-tight, corrosion-resistant, low-resistance, and electrically conductive mechanical connection that is also suitable for potting. It is also specified in DIN EN 60352-5 and maintains reliable contact even under very high mechanical and thermal stresses, such as vibration, bending, and extreme temperature changes, and can even withstand shock loads of up to 200g.
 
Due to its outstanding robustness and a failure-in-transit (FIT) rate ten times lower than that of automated soldered connectors, press-fit technology is frequently used in high-security applications where signal transmission must not be interrupted under any circumstances, such as in airbag systems or ABS and ESP modules.
Meniskusbildung
Fig. 9: Uniform meniscus formation around the solder pad of the One27
However, press-fit technology is not always suitable, for example, when PCBs need to be populated on both sides or when the minimum clearance from components in the direction of force cannot be maintained. Another option for creating a reliable and durable connection between the connector and the PCB is surface-mount technology (SMT). In this process, solder paste is used to solder the connectors to defined connection areas on the PCB, known as solder pads. Only in a so-called reflow oven is the solder melted and then allowed to harden. SMT enables the creation of stable connections between the connector and the PCB. However, several criteria must be met for this: First, for a solder joint compliant with the IPC-A-610 standard, the correct ratio of solder ball, solder pad, and solder paste must be maintained. Only in this way can a high-quality connection be established that enables a connection according to IPC Class 3, making it suitable for use in high-performance electronics. Failures in signal transmission must be ruled out at all times in this class. An optimal solder joint is characterized by uniform meniscus formation, with the contact completely surrounded by the solder meniscus to achieve the best holding forces on the printed circuit board (Fig. 9). 
The coplanarity of the contact pins is essential for an excellent connection. When all these requirements are met, SMT connectors have been proven to withstand mechanical loads of up to 400 N.

Design of the insulating body as an influencing factor

ept Mitten Winkel Versatz
Fig. 10: The Zero8 connector allows for a center offset of ±0.7 mm and an angular offset of 4°.
 The insulation body geometry of a connector also helps protect the contacts from damage during operation or installation. It should be designed so that the vulnerable contacts are shielded inside the connector.

 Lead-in chamfers can also prevent damage during assembly. They help compensate for any misalignment of the circuit boards in any direction during mating. With the aid of an additional catch area, the two connector halves can be mated without damage even in the event of a center or angular misalignment (Fig. 10).

ept Boardlock
Fig. 11: Boardlock on the One27
Some connectors also feature board locks. These are metal brackets attached to the insulator and soldered to the printed circuit board (Fig. 11). This provides additional stability—even under adverse conditions such as vibration and shock.

Influencing factor Tolerance range

Toleranzausgleich im Betrieb
Fig. 12: zero8 tolerance compensation in all directions
The tolerance range of a connector plays a crucial role in assessing its robustness. If the connector cannot compensate for given tolerances, mechanical movements will lead to wear or even damage to the connection. During installation, insertion chamfers help ensure that the male and female connectors can be mated without damage. However, micro-movements must also be accommodated when the connector is mated. This is achieved through the geometry of the contacts and insulating bodies. If a connector has a floating function, it can compensate for up to ±0.4 mm even during operation. This function is becoming increasingly important, as it plays a crucial role when a printed circuit board is populated with multiple connectors. In the field, however, stresses arise not only in the x and y directions but also in the z direction (Fig. 12).

UEberstecksicherheit
Fig. 13: Overlap range of 1.5 mm and 0.9 mm provides additional contact reliability with the One27
This raises the question of a connector’s overlap security. This refers to the overlap area between the male and female contacts, thereby allowing not only for different PCB spacing but also—depending on the size of this area—for tolerance ranges (Fig. 13).

Maximum tolerance compensation, on the other hand, is achieved using a cable connection. Here, the length of the cable determines the tolerance range of the connector.

Testing procedure

Zero8 nach Kombi Pruefung
Fig. 14: Undamaged contacts of the zero8 socket after passing the insertion cycle and corrosive gas testing
 There are various testing methods available to thoroughly evaluate the durability characteristics of connectors. These methods involve measuring variables such as dielectric strength and contact resistance both before and after a stress test, as well as visually inspecting the condition of the contacts. For example, the effects of 500 mating cycles on dielectric strength can be assessed, or a climatic test can determine whether several hours at -55°C followed by 125°C have a negative impact on the contact resistance of the connector. In the temperature shock test, the connector must withstand rapid cycling between these extreme temperatures 100 times for 30 minutes each. Furthermore, the center and angular misalignment during mating, as well as the tolerance range in the mated state, should not only be verified theoretically on the CAD model but also extensively tested in practice, with the load-bearing capacity confirmed empirically. It is equally important that various tests critical to the contact surface be performed in combination to simulate real-world conditions. For example, mating cycle and corrosive gas tests could be conducted in combination to ensure that the connector’s performance in terms of contact resistance and dielectric strength has not deteriorated and that the contacts have not been damaged (Fig. 14). 

Your Design - Your Choice

Bewerbungsprozess Icons 2000x1457px Gluehbirne FREI
Depending on the application requirements, there are various durability criteria that a connector must meet. For example, does it need to compensate for wide tolerances? Is it exposed to high shock loads or vibrations? Will it be used in environments subject to extreme heat or cold? Or does the connection solution need to be protected against moisture, corrosive gases, or dirt? By addressing these factors when selecting a connection solution, users can ensure that the chosen connector is optimally equipped for its intended field application. 

Your message has been sent.

Thank you for your interest—we will process your request as soon as possible.

Contact Form

Fields marked with * are required.

Personal information

Recall

Your message

I am interested in

Information materials

Privacy Policy

You can view our privacy policy here.

Thank you very much!

We will be in touch shortly to discuss your requirements. We will prepare and send you a detailed report on the high-speed characteristics as well as S-parameters for simulating your own design.

Request high-speed specifications and S-parameters to simulate your own design

Fields marked with * are required.
You can view our privacy policy here.

Thank you very much for your interest

You can download the white paper here:

Download the white paper

Before you can download the white paper, please fill out the following fields. Thank you.

Fields marked with * are required.

Personal information

Would you like to send us more information?

I am interested in

Privacy Policy

You can view our privacy policy here.

Thank you for your inquiry

We will review your request and get back to you as soon as possible.

Request a quote for custom connectors

Fields marked with an * are required; please fill them in.

Contact person

Your request

Wrong file format! Please select a PDF or JPG file.
You can view our privacy policy here.

Thank you for your inquiry

We will review your request and get back to you as soon as possible.

Your requirements for the connector

Fields marked with an * are required; please fill them in.

Contact person

Your request

Wrong file format! Please select a PDF or JPG file.
You can view our privacy policy here.